The Procurement Institution Release 2026.11

Primers/Definitions/Mandatory vs rated criteria

DefinitionAnswer-firstRelease 2026.11Methodology

Mandatory vs rated criteria

Mandatory and rated criteria are the two halves of every public evaluation. Mandatory criteria are binary gates — insurance levels, certifications, security clearances, minimum experience — where failure disqualifies the proposal outright, regardless of quality elsewhere. Rated criteria are the scored dimensions (technical approach, personnel, past performance) on which compliant proposals are compared and ranked.

The discipline is to never confuse the two kinds of effort. Mandatory gates are not winnable — only clearable — so they deserve checklist-level attention and nothing more; the recurring failure is a strong proposal disqualified over a stale certificate. Rated criteria are where the competition actually happens, and the grid's weighting tells you how much each point costs in effort. Before drafting, split the solicitation into the two lists; it takes twenty minutes and it is the highest-return editorial act in proposal strategy.

Canada-side deep dives on PubSec.Pro: How RFP evaluation criteria are weighted and Acceptance Criteria.

Cite this page

The Procurement Institution. (2026). Mandatory vs rated criteria — definition. https://procurementinstitution.org/definitions/mandatory-vs-rated-criteria

@misc{pi-2026-definitions-mandatory-vs-rated-criteria,
  author = {{The Procurement Institution}},
  title  = {Mandatory vs rated criteria — definition},
  year   = {2026},
  url    = {https://procurementinstitution.org/definitions/mandatory-vs-rated-criteria},
  note   = {Release 2026.11}
}

Live Opportunities

Live federal and provincial procurement opportunities, tracked in one free feed.

Find live opportunities in Canadian procurement →